My adult kids lived a charmed life this past week.
One went to Los Angeles. The other went to Atlanta.
Both of them flew commercial airliners. Both of them took off on time. Both of them landed on time. Both ways.
That flies in the face, so to speak, of what thousands of American air travelers experienced.
On Friday, the Federal Aviation Administration issued a full ground stop of all flights. The agency says a data flood from either a radar site in Texas or a data site in Arkansas. As many satirists pointed out, the problem is similar to when the goofy air controller pulls the plug in the slapstick comedy “Airplane!”
That one or even two local malfunctions can foil an entire air system troubles a lot of people. But that’s not the issue I’m as interested in as…
Why this country has no reasonable alternatives to flying? Not only from New York to Los Angeles, but even from New York to Pittsburgh or Los Angeles to Phoenix.
Of course, driving is an option. But right now, gas is $4 a gallon in New York and $6 a gallon in Los Angeles. And the fastest you can legally go is about 70 mph outside L.A. and 65 once you get to the New Jersey Turnpike from Manhattan.
The getting there poses the problem. At the wrong time, it takes hours to clear large metropolitan areas. Four years ago, driving from LAX to Palm Springs, about 100 miles away, took us close to five hours.
And more people on the road makes that mode even more problematic.
All this is an excuse for me to get on one of my favorite soapboxes: We have failed, miserably, to develop reasonable high-speed mass alternatives to airplanes.
Don’t say trains. They don’t work here. Maybe in the corridor between Boston and Washington, although you pay quite the premium for Acela trains that run just a bit faster than cars.
But we don’t have Europe’s high-speed intercity rail system. Or Asia’s. And any effort to build something like that, such as in central California or between Florida’s biggest cities, lag efforts in other parts of the world.
Had there been some alternative to air travel, Friday wouldn’t have been such a crisis to so many families. “Hey, honey, there’s some kind of problem with the air traffic system, but I’m switching over to the New York-Chicago rail line. I should home in about four hours.”
Right now, the fastest train between two of the nation’s three largest cities takes 19-1/2 hours. Not much different from what it took Cary Grant and Eva Marie Saint in “North by Northwest.”
The fact is we never prioritize transportation alternatives. From one part of a rural county to another. From one part of a city to another. From one part of a state to another. From one region of the nation to another.
You fly or you drive. That’s it.
We’ve solved problems in other fields. Think about it. There’s no difference in the train ride from New York to Chicago from “North by Northwest,” released 67 years ago.
A remake would give Roger Thornhill, Cary Grant’s character, an iPhone 18 or a Samsung Galaxy 26. He could look up who’s after him while he’s hiding on the train. He could even be tracked on the train by the FBI.
It would still take the same 19-1/2 hours. Technology gets the bucks for making changes.
Blame the legacy American industries of oil, auto and aerospace. The last century has been in their interest to keep things the way they are. It’s why electric cars took a lot longer to develop than you would have thought. It’s why a lot of other alternatives to petroleum remain unexplored.
And these folks invested big time in the current president. Why not? He and the wizards he seems to attract to his menagerie of an administration don’t care about, understand or approve of alternatives. A lot of them still believe solar energy won’t work if it’s raining, or that birds can’t figure out how to avoid an offshore windmill.
As our current systems break down, and change our climate to spark crazy El Ninos and massive rainfall in places that aren’t used to it, we’re going to be stuck until we come up with alternatives.
That’s one more thing on the agenda of the new Congress. Coming up with creative tickets to ride – wherever we’re going – shows a concern for our future. Maybe not in my lifetime, but perhaps when our kids are our age, they’ll thank us for giving them a lift.
By coincidence, I finished reading Jill Lepore’s Pulitzer-winning book about the history of the Constitution, “We The People,” just as the 2026 midterm election came to its wonderful conclusion.
If you’re not familiar with it, Lepore’s book is a detailed accounting of efforts to either change the Constitution or, failing that, reading it in a way that changes its meaning from time to time.
Because the amendment process in Article V makes that kind of change extremely difficult, we’ve more often relied on how the nine people on the Supreme Court interpret the document.
Liberals are fine with that when the results are something like Brown v. Board of Education that ended segregated schools or Oberkfell v. Hodges which legalized same-sex marriage.
Conservatives are fine with that when Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization ends the right to abortion in many states or when Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission allows corporations to spent unlimited money on campaigns.
Thanks to Trump, the conservatives hold sway on the court right now. They hold a super majority – six of the nine justices are right-wing. In fact, the three justices picked by Trump are only nearly as bad as Clarence Thomas, named by George H.W. Bush, and Samuel Alito, selected by Bush’s son.
And, because the High Court is MAGA in black robes instead of red hats, and both houses of Congress acted like trained seals under Republican leadership, Trump and his unmerry band ran roughshod over norms, laws and Constitutional provisions. RIP, emoluments clause.
Trump proved the Constitution contains loopholes – and he drove a giant ballroom through them. Sure, courts might eventually catch up with his crime spree. But a lot of damage will be done – lives lost, lives ruined, peace disturbed, an economy savaged, landmarks wrecked or destroyed.
The Democrats won a bigger victory than any of us dared imagine. Bigger than even the victories Republicans won earlier this century in a deck stacked by gerrymandering and voter suppression. In Congress, in governors’ mansions, in state legislatures.
And still, they’re not close to being able to effect the changes that are needed. Because to amend the U.S. Constitution, two-thirds of both houses of Congress must approve the proposal. And then three-quarters of the state legislatures – that’s 38 as of now – have to OK the change.
What Constitutional amendment do you think could possibly pass in Alabama AND Vermont?Utah AND New York? California AND Oklahoma?
So the kinds of changes Democrats need to make must go around but not against the Constitution. It’s like playing Operation, the board game – if you try to remove the organ, you can’t trip the buzzer. Which in this case is John Roberts and his merry band at SCOTUS.
But Democrats can’t do nothing. They campaigned on the idea of making changes to root out corruption and preserving democracy. That goes hand-in-hand with the affordability mantra – political graft is contributing to the high cost of everything.
One slam dunk is to pass ethics reforms for all branches of the federal government – legislative, judicial and executive..
This means no stock trading. No starting businesses while in office. Putting existing investments into a blind trust, No working as a lobbyist for a certain amount of time after you leave office. No gifts above $100 – there’s no problem accepting a tin of cookies from Girl Scouts, but paid-for trips and real estate are ridiculous.
Would the tame right-wing Supreme Court strike that down? Maybe. Show them for what they are and pass the legislation anyway.
And one more thing: If a judicial or executive nominee refuses to accept these guidelines, there should be a coalition of senators and representatives, from both parties, saying they will vote “No” regardless of their political affiliation.
It’s unlikely we can get rid of the Electoral College. And I’m not sure the popular vote compact – awarding a state’s electoral vote to the national popular vote winner – is a particularly good idea.
if I voted for the national vote loser, and he or she carried my state, I doubt I’d be crazy about the state casting our electoral votes for the other candidate.
We’re also going to have a hard time getting rid of Citizens United. But Montana and Hawaii have enacted legislation limiting the influence corporations have on elections. That should be something the other 48 states do, too.
The Democrats can’t really enact some other needed reforms that Trump can veto – adding seats to the Supreme Court and statehood for the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico.
Also, adding seats to the House of Representatives to make it more reflective of the actual population. California has one seat for every 757,000 people. Wyoming has one for all of its 589,000. That’s more than a 20% underrepresentation for California.
——
One other thought: There should never be another U.S. Supreme Court Justice who states a belief that the Constitution needs to be interpreted through the prism of the original intent of its authors.
That is absolutely ridiculous. It ascribes infallibility to a bunch of guys who still owned slaves. Who read by candlelight, cooked on an open fire and took a week to get from New York to Washington.
It’s doubtful “Hamilton” would be the success it is if Lin-Manuel Miranda wrote it in the form of minuets and chorales instead of hip-hop and rock.
That’s what original intent means to me. The Constitution should be a living document; it should adapt to the times. That means the Second Amendment should be interpreted to take into account weapons of mass destruction, that the Fourth Amendment be interpreted to understand how much easier to search individuals in a technological age.
——
You can’t be sure whether the massive Democratic victory this month is a harbinger of a shift in Americans’ attitudes. We thought the U.S. was “past racism” when it overwhelmingly elected a Black president in 2008 – and think about what’s happened since.
But with a little vigilance, we can begin the process of emerging from the darkness of the past decade.
Change is coming. Let’s hope it’s good – and that the good sticks.
The way it usually works, kids make wish lists for the holidays and then get the shiny new toy.
Tuesday’s election reverses that. Democrats found the toy early the next morning. And now, they have a wish list of what they want to do with it.
I felt pretty sure the Democrats would take the House; they only needed three flips. I hoped they would take the Senate with maybe 52 seats so that the possible defection of Pennsylvania’s John Fetterman wouldn’t matter.
But like most Democrats, I dreaded Election Night. Kamala Harris was certain to win. So was Hillary Clinton eight years before.
Instead, the Trumpian dystopia.
The actual results felt like I got the bicycle, the baseball mitt and the video game console, instead of just the console.
The Democrats gained at least 24 House seats and are predicted by NBC News to gain 41.They’ll hold something in the vicinity of 258 seats; the Republicans have been bullying people with just 220.
They took control of the Senate with a minimum of 54 seats. Two races, not yet called, are leaning their way.
Those margins loom large. Donald Trump can’t pass anything or get anyone appointed to the executive or judicial branches without carving out something around 40 Democratic votes in the House. Given what the electorate said about his policies, that ain’t likely.
So what can we do with this thing?
The kind of sweeping legislation to expand healthcare, reverse the Supreme Court abortion decision and other Democratic priorities doesn’t seem possible. Trump already indicated he’ll veto stuff willy nilly.
But Democrats can’t fear that. If there’s legislation to undo the healthcare cuts that go into effect as a result of the tax cut passed in the current Congress, go for it. Let Trump veto a bill to lower Americans’ costs. That’s the campaign poster for 2028.
If there’s legislation to help get gas prices down, let Trump veto it. And, as it stands, not funding the idiotic war against Iran probably helps that cause.
A push on ethics reform would also go over well. Ban stock trading by members of all three branches of government. Ban gifts worth more than $200 to anyone in government. Limit lobbyists’ influence. Again, if Trump vetoes, make ethics issues an ad subject in the next election.
There’s always a chance surviving Republicans now see the light and want to show they understand that affordability isn’t a hoax. $4-a-gallon and $6-a-gallon diesel are the primary reasons for Tuesday night. Not the only ones, but likely the biggest ones.
It is a Democratic tradition to let bygones be bygones. My saying is Democrats want to govern, Republicans want to rule. Governing means you do litigate the past in order to get your priorities done.
That’s over. The Merrick Garland memorial deliberate speed on investigations needs to join Garland in retirement.
Investigations into what most of us believe are serious crimes against the nation are fair game. Theft of our tax dollars, sweetheart contracts to political cronies, the enrichment of the Trump family and all the other crap we’ve dealt with since January 20, 2025.
We can walk and chew gum at the same time. Legislate for the good of the American people. Investigate for the justice Americans crave.
I don’t believe impeaching Trump serves a purpose. He’s 80 years old, he’s a senile bat and, most of all, there aren’t enough votes to convict. Making him a martyr for the fourth time – two prior impeachments and a questionable assassination attempt – isn’t a good idea.
But, by all means, haul the Trump kids – yes, even Barron – and Jared Kushner before Congress. Make them testify. If they don’t, find them in contempt. Yes, eventually Trump will pardon them – and lots and lots of other people. But put their perfidy on the public record – and help the state attorneys general develop cases that Trump can’t wash away.
And, there are people who might be worth impeaching. Pete Hegseth mismanaged the precious resource of the world’s strongest military, firing generals and admirals who didn’t meet his political or bizarre masculinity standards.
I love that one of the Democrats who appears to have won in South Carolina is Nancy Lacore, a vice admiral Hegseth forced into retirement. Another is my congresswoman-elect, Cait Conley, who spent 16 years in the military and worked protecting national security. Let’s see how macho Hegseth is when these veterans go at him.
There’s even talk that a Hegseth impeachment might take place in the lame duck Congress. That would be a sign that some Republicans learned a lesson.
Another impeachment candidate is Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., the Health and Human Services secretary. His tenure includes such amazing accomplishments as the return of measles, lettuce that gave people exploding diarrhea and the encouragement of vaccine skepticism that endangers large swaths of the population.
There are Republicans who would happily throw Kennedy under the bus – which he might actually think of as a fitness regimen.
What Democrats can’t do is business as usual. Their model for how they should operate is 250 miles north of the Capitol.
Zohran Mamdani won election as New York’s mayor a year ago. He spent that year doing a lot of the stuff he was going to do – along with creating an image of NYC as a place of joy and striving. If Democrats follow his path and do things that make life more affordable and maybe even fun, their shiny new toy will last a lot longer than the ones under the tree.
Congratulations to any of you who root for the Seattle Seahawks.
Being a former sportswriter, I know that a winning Super Bowl team is the one that executes its game plan better. On Sunday, the Seahawks’ plan appeared to be focusing on the younger members of the New England Patriots’ offensive line and pressuring their quarterback. The Patriots came close to figuring it out in the fourth quarter, but came up short.
There’s a lesson here for the forces trying to undo the mess that is the United States of America.
We have midterm elections in nine months. In special and off-year elections leading up to November, Democrats are far outperforming the norms. They’ve captured legislative seats in what were thought to be safe Trump districts and taken over municipalities previously run by Republicans.
Democrats are winning because most Americans are sick of this Trump crap. They’ve seen the U.S. embarrassed on the world stage, the economy slide, and the disgrace of mass arrests and extrajudicial murder by the human waste known as ICE.
But success can only be fueled by anger for only so long – although I suspect people are so angry that this feeling will last longer than usual.
Democrats – and the non-Democrats who can’t stand what’s happening to our country – need to come up with a game plan. One that will spell out what they plan to do to not only end the nightmare of Trump II, but to make life genuinely better for the 342 million-plus Americans who aren’t billionaires.
This plan should not be developed by a liberal think tank, or by the groups perceived as being on the left.
It should be developed by the people who it affects. What the Democrats need to do is travel the country listening to the problems people have – and then sounding out solutions.
Take healthcare, which until the Trump threat to democracy was probably the biggest problem people in this country faced.
I’m on Medicare, so healthcare costs are merely outrageous. For many people who aren’t 65, they border on catastrophic. The cost of taking care of yourself and your loved ones should not be an impediment to your financial viability.
The country might finally be ready for universal healthcare. Maybe Medicare for All. Maybe even something as advanced as Britain’s NHS.
But Democrats need to get their push for this from the American people. The ones who are paying outrageous premiums, who are committing huge chunks of their financial wherewithal to pay for prescriptions Having town halls throughout the country – forget the blue state/red state thing – is an important way to get a public impetus for improving healthcare.
Pointing out that Trump is constantly proclaiming that he’s “two weeks away” from a great plan to replace the Affordable Care Act, drawing up a plan – maybe naming it for a place where a town hall came to a solid conclusion – and then getting just about every Democrat running for the House, the Senate and the statehouses to stand behind that plan.
That’s what needs to be done to ensure Democrats are not just using rage bait. That it’s finally time to stop screwing around with people’s lives and start making those lives better.
And not just with healthcare. Infrastructure. Immigration. Women’s rights. Climate change. Campaign finance reform. Ending corruption.
This isn’t that original. In our lifetime, the Republicans have run on the Contract for America and Project 2025 – and as miserable as they are, they’ve executed them well.
The New Deal is an example on our side – we’re still reaping the benefits of FDR’s vision and the impetus for real change. It led to the Democratic Party controlling Congress pretty steadily from the 1930s to the 1980s.
It’s a game plan. Just like what the Seahawks executed in Super Bowl LX. Only this time, both Pioneer Square and Copley Square – and every place in between – will find reason to celebrate.
Last week, I contended that my generation of baby boomers is a disappointing lot.
This week, a generation of younger New Yorkers agreed.
That’s what I make of Zohran Mamdani’s surprising win in the Democratic primary of mayor of New York. Actually, Mamdani hasn’t won yet, but he’s well first in the first tabulation of ballots in the city’s ranked-choice voting, and runner-up Andrew Cuomo already conceded.
If he wins the general election in November – he’ll be favored but is not a lock – the 33-year-old Mamdani would be one of the youngest mayors in the city’s 400-year history. Jeez, he’s younger than my daughter.
And that – more than any other reason – might be why Mamdani shocked the city’s political establishment.
At age 71, there’s nothing I can drink or eat that gives me the boost of energy from walking the streets of New York. Like so many other great cities, it’s where young people flock to eat, to listen, to play, to watch, to have fun. It moves fast. Its active residents want nothing more than to be able to move at their own pace without encumbrance.
Most of all, it’s a city tired of being encumbered by a generation that believes tall buildings and luxury define greatness.
New York is about waiting in line 40 minutes for a $5 roast pork takeout dinner in Chinatown. New York is about sitting by the Central Park Reservoir while a four-person jazz combo performs a stunning rendition of “Embraceable You.” New York is about art around you, strange outfits, unisex bathrooms and the quest for the perfect pizza slice.
Mamdani seems to understand that.
The people in the Democratic establishment don’t. They think they’re living in a city that requires the approval of the monied class to fund development. They fall back on people with well-known names and older celebrities as if they – and not the young people in pubs and bodegas – are the city’s future.
I don’t live in New York City – I live north and west, in a place that’s trying its damnedest to be nothing like New York City. But because the people who live in the ‘burbs often depend on the city, they resent it.
That’s all crystallized in the congestion pricing debate. Nobody around here wants to pay $15 to drive south of 60th Street in Manhattan, and they see a toll for doing that as a violation of their privilege to use their car wherever the hell they want.
People who live in the congestion pricing zone love it. There’s less traffic, making the streets safer to cross. There’s less noise and pollution. Less horn honking. Buses run faster. Ambulances have fewer obstacles.
Mamdani seems to stand for ideas like that. He wants to find a way to make bus service free and faster.
He supports the idea of collective city-run supermarkets – not, as residents of Park Slope in Brooklyn know, a completely novel idea. This way, those who are less affluent don’t have to pay the gouged prices you can find at a Morton Williams or Gristedes – supermarket chains you and your wallet should be grateful aren’t in your area.
Mamdani’s win has shaken up New York politics and has the TV talking heads chattering. It has Republicans laser focused on demonizing him in order to get one of its longshots to squeak through. And it has the national Democrats in a quandary – do we embrace or ignore this guy?
So here are four thoughts:
— TRUMP: If you don’t think Mamdani’s win has something to do with Trump, you aren’t paying attention.
This is absolutely New York Democrats wanting not to feel powerless in the fight against a dictatorship. This is absolutely an entire segment of the populace saying that we’re giving up on trying to triangulate against Trump, let’s take the stupid bastard on.
Trump knows it. He went after Mamdani in one of those whatever-he-calls-a-Truth-Social posts.
Good. Let’s take the freakin’ gloves off.
— THE MIDDLE EAST: When I was young, there was a beer commercial highlighting New York’s diversity. Each had a tagline – for instance, for Italians, it would be “In New York City, where there are more than Italians than in the whole of Naples, more people drink Rheingold…”
For Jewish New Yorkers, it was “In New York City, where there are more Jews than in the whole of Israel, more people drink Rheingold…”
That was true back then. It’s not now, but New York City is as great as it is in part because of Jewish influence. New Yorkers schlep, they buy tchotchkes, they eat knishes – and all 8 million of them know what those phrases mean.
So Israel is a big issue here, much more so than in any other locality in the U.S. and maybe the world.
Mamdani is Muslim. That’s the background to the fact that he doesn’t support what the Netanyahu government has done in Gaza. He didn’t dance around it. He made one unfortunate comment that gave opponents ammunition to say he’s antisemitic.
He’s not. Opposing Netanyahu and what’s happened in Gaza is not anti-Israel. As I said last week – and stand by – no one has done as much to reignite antisemitism in the world as Benjamin Netanyahu.
I suspect Mamdani will be more assertive about supporting Israeli’s right to exist as much as he supports the Palestinians’ right to self-determination – he kind of mumbled that in his appearance of “The Late Show with Stephen Colbert” this week.
Importantly, Mamdani garnered a lot of support from Jewish voters who are as heartsick about Gaza as they are about what Hamas did to kids and the elderly in October 2023. And his collaboration with one of his opponents who is Jewish, city comptroller Brad Lander, is meant to show that Mamdani will work with others to make the city a more affordable place to live.
THE DEVIL (aka SOCIALISM): Americans are conditioned to believe socialism is evil. It’s something the wealthiest among us have pushed since the Gilded Age.
In particular, because they take on the mantle of being “socialist,” communist states such as the Soviet Union and China are what are sold as being the outcome of turning toward socialism.
That’s not right. At all. We already have some vestiges of socialism. Defense contractors and farmers receive subsidies from the federal government. Most public transportation is run by local government agencies.
That’s not going to stop Mamdani’s opponents from conjuring images of empty store shelves and fleeing businesses if he’s elected.
But the real socialism Mamdani proposes is best seen in his plans for small businesses. He wants the city to foster small businesses – provide subsidies, cut fees and fines, offer mentoring programs to get new enterprises going.
That is what people want.
New Yorkers may have swallowed hard and realized they’re socialists after all. Now those who can’t stand that idea – think hedge fund managers and other moguls – need to decide if they want to do without being in the city.
If so, here’s my thought: Don’t let the limo door hit you on the way out.
DEMOCRATS: We’re now five-plus months into the dark world of Trumpdom II. Sternly worded letters, lawsuits, those endless fund-raising e-mails haven’t done much to make the Democratic party more palatable to the people who rejected it last November. For all of Trump’s plunge in polling, there’s been no political coalescing force.
Maybe Mamdani is the answer. But not in the way Democrats like to think.
The lazy thing would be to think the country is ready for a turn left as exemplified by Mamdani. And it does seem as though New York City might be ready for that after years of being run by supposedly business friendly types: Rudy Giuliani, Mike Bloomberg and Eric Adams.
But what Mamdani did was tap into what New Yorkers want for their city. His little ads were entertaining – watch the one about Halalinflation for a sense of what really matters.
Instead of preaching from a hill, Mamdani and his supporters traveled the city and understood the problems. And that’s what Democrats around the country need to do.
They do not need to mimic Mamdani’s policy ideas. They need to listen first and then adopt a plan of action that fits the community.
It might very well be more conservative. People in western Pennsylvania or Scottsdale or northern Minnesota might have their own unique issues that require action.
Listen and respond. Get a plan together. Adapt to your constituency. Be smart and engaged about it. No knee-jerk, one-size-fits-all solutions. I love New York, but I don’t think central Wisconsin should be a rural version of it.
In the midst of 100-degree heat and the casual “let’s lob a few bombs into Iran” during the past week, Mamdani’s primary win seems like a moment to cheer. It will certainly make for a little brightness among the gloom – especially if he can further build his coalition from now until November.
When he isn’t busy pardoning fraudsters whose family members donate money to him, Donald Trump has the wrecking crew he assembled as a cabinet working to destroy this country.
Commercially exploiting federal land. Denying the effectiveness of vaccination in combatting disease and illness. Pissing off our traditional allies. Attempting to destroy one of the world’s most prestigious universities.
It’s like what the team the arch-villain in a superhero movie conjures. Except I don’t see any Bruce Waynes or Clark Kents in the neighborhood.
And the Democratic Party, the force best suited in this moment to fight back, is engaged in circular firing squad mode.
But Elissa Slotkin, the recently elected junior senator from Michigan, has one idea that might start to turn things around.
Slotkin suggests that the Democrats form a shadow Cabinet – a team of experts that mimics the roles of the actual team of horribles Trump assembled.
While a shadow Cabinet would have none of the enforcement power of its MAGA stooge counterpart, it would help give the Democratic Party something it needs desperately: a plan.
The “secretaries” would help to develop policies – in the same way the party develops a platform just before the quadrennial convention. Those policies would serve as alternatives to what Trump and his henchpeople are doing to America’s government and image.
For instance, with the Republicans seemingly determined to undermine Medicaid and strip it away from millions of people who need it, a shadow Health and Human Services Secretary could propose an expansion of the Affordable Care Act – aka Obamacare. That would further reduce medical costs for all Americans and stand in stark contrast.
Put that out there and see what happens. There’s a chance it could force the MAGA idiots to reconsider their plan – they’ll argue it’s socialism or whatever, but they’ll feel some pressure. As opposed to now, when all they’re hearing is that what they’re doing is bad.
Come up with an alternative that someone articulate can sell – and it doesn’t look like “he said, she said” politics as usual.
That’s the thing. The Democrats have an advantage in that most of the people who speak as leaders of the party can do so in complete sentences. From Barack Obama to AOC to Pete Buttigieg to Tim Walz, the party knows how to communicate effectively.
But a shadow Cabinet should not contain people who might be running for the White House in 2028. Or, obviously Obama – unlike the Republicans, Democrats take Constitutional term limits seriously.
Not sure exactly who that is just yet. But it could be AOC, Buttigieg, maybe Walz, Gretchen Whitmer, Gavin Newsom or Kamala Harris.
That doesn’t mean there isn’t talent to make the Democrats’ case.
Politico recently gave 21 names for a Democratic shadow Cabinet. Some of them are outright silly. Ben Stein is a hardcore Republican and I’d bet money he voted for Trump; just because his character in “Ferris Bueller’s Day Off” bemoans tariffs doesn’t mean he’ll stand up against them in real life. He’s also 80 years old.
And Jon Stewart, while incredibly potent as an advocate for veterans, is much more effective as a nonpartisan lampooner than serving as a party spokesman.
But some of the other names are interesting.
Letitia James, New York’s attorney general, has stood up to Trump before and even won a civil fraud case against him and his company. She is a no-nonsense law enforcement advocate and – as a native Brooklynite – isn’t afraid to speak her mind.
Samantha Power knows how foreign aid makes our country safer. She headed USAID when it was giving money to fight disease and hunger around the world – something Trump and Marco Rubio, his Secretary of State, feel is too “woke.” Having her out front as a defender of America’s generosity and compassion is a visual I’d be proud to see.
However, the personalities aren’t important. As I’ve said since January 20, the Democrats can’t just be against Trump. They have to stand for something more than returning to the status quo. They need to understand that people are frustrated with the direction of the country and want their lives to be easier.
Joe Biden understood that, but his limitations made that hard to sell – he couldn’t go to a lot of college campuses or big stadium rallies the way Barack Obama could. The Democrats need a plan of action and a bunch of articulate leaders of all varieties to go out and spell out a better future – and then watch Trump stew as those plans catch fire with the public.
It’ll take some work. But it’ll be worth it. Often bad things lurk in shadows, but they provide shade from a burning sun. And right now, the America we love is getting scorched – a little Democratic shadowing could help.
My son took an improvisational comedy class this winter – and his class show was last Sunday.
It was a good hour of solid laughter as he and his fellow quick-thinkers responded to the moment with some hilarious ideas.
As his class instructor said at the conclusion, that was the only time that show will ever be seen quite that way. The next time, it will be somewhat different, funnier or maybe not.
Improvisation is a great form of comedy.
It’s a lousy strategy for fighting would-be dictators.
Right now, Democrats are wisely capitalizing on the nonchalance of Trump’s national security team, which accidentally gave a journalist access to deliberations on this month’s strike against Houthi rebels in Yemen.
No one claims to know how Jeffrey Goldberg, editor-in-chief of The Atlantic, was included in what should have been a top-secret chat on the messaging service Signal.
In the process, Trump and his Trumpettes have blamed Goldberg, called it an accident, told two versions of what they knew about the situation, blamed AOC, asked if it might have been a nefarious plot by Signal workers, said the dog did it, blamed Joe Biden and anything else you can think of. Not all of that is real, but given how these people are, you might be tempted to think it’s possible they used all those alibis.
Here’s the thing: I would be surprised if anyone loses their job because of this. Even Party Pete Hegseth, the Defense Secretary and White Lotus wannabe.
Accidentally broadcasting American military operations and putting the lives of brave men and women at risk is only a mild stretch from sexual predation, persecution, family destruction, illegal deportation, violations of free speech and 34 felony counts of fraud.
And if, by some stroke of unusual competence in Team Trump, somebody does get canned, what does that mean for the quality and integrity of the U.S. executive branch?
Bupkis.
It doesn’t matter if Pete Hegseth or Peat Moss holds the title of Defense Secretary, even if they have the same level of intelligence.
See, the thing is, Trump and the Republicans aren’t improvising. They’re working from a script. And they will stick to the script no matter who the actors are.
Their script is to weaken and decimate the federal government. And nothing – not even a scandal involving the basic idea that YOU DON’T TELL EVERYONE YOUR SECRET MILITARY PLANS – will cause them to ad lib.
They told you what they were going to do when they put out their Project 2025 playbook. And even when Trump went around denying he knew anything about a plan he almost certainly approved, did you ever believe the Republicans wouldn’t abide by it?
And that brings me to the Democrats.
We are good at getting mad. Reacting in the moment to some injustice or wrongdoing. Our lawmakers ask the piercing questions at committee hearings. We create clever memes and social media posts.
What Democrats don’t do is plan.
It’s almost as if they expect would-be voters to trust that they’ll find some way to attain the ideals they proclaim. But they don’t have a blueprint to get to that point.
And people like blueprints. They like specifics. They like benchmarks to gauge progress and ideas.
Democrats are afraid of ideas. They’re afraid people will shoot them down.
Try them. Instead of saying we think education needs to be reformed, ask people what they want for their kids and then work with them to attain those goals. Instead of saying we need to take care of our elderly, ask seniors and their caregivers what’s needed and figure out how we get to that point.
If people are angry about their healthcare options, see what’s troubling your constituents and then work toward it.
Trying to fight the drive toward Project 2025 won’t come ad hoc. It is, to be sure, extremely unpopular – it polled so badly that Trump and the others denied it existed even though it was in print and online for all to see. Once they won, they just went back to the plan as if it was a mandate.
The advantage Democrats will have if they develop an action agenda in consultation with the people showing up at town halls is that people will support it. Make it a genuine grassroots idea, and they’ll back you to the hilt.
It’s well and good to improvise a reaction to a security scandal or whatever Trump’s next A.S.S. (Act of Shame and Stupidity) is. But you can’t wing your way to win the hearts of your fellow Americans.