Uncategorized

LIONS AND TIGERS AND SOCIALISTS, OH, MY!

Last week, I contended that my generation of baby boomers is a disappointing lot.

This week, a generation of younger New Yorkers agreed.

That’s what I make of Zohran Mamdani’s surprising win in the Democratic primary of mayor of New York. Actually, Mamdani hasn’t won yet, but he’s well first in the first tabulation of ballots in the city’s ranked-choice voting, and runner-up Andrew Cuomo already conceded.

If he wins the general election in November – he’ll be favored but is not a lock – the 33-year-old Mamdani would be one of the youngest mayors in the city’s 400-year history. Jeez, he’s younger than my daughter.

And that – more than any other reason – might be why Mamdani shocked the city’s political establishment.

At age 71, there’s nothing I can drink or eat that gives me the boost of energy from walking the streets of New York. Like so many other great cities, it’s where young people flock to eat, to listen, to play, to watch, to have fun. It moves fast. Its active residents want nothing more than to be able to move at their own pace without encumbrance.

Most of all, it’s a city tired of being encumbered by a generation that believes tall buildings and luxury define greatness.

New York is about waiting in line 40 minutes for a $5 roast pork takeout dinner in Chinatown. New York is about sitting by the Central Park Reservoir while a four-person jazz combo performs a stunning rendition of “Embraceable You.” New York is about art around you, strange outfits, unisex bathrooms and the quest for the perfect pizza slice.

Mamdani seems to understand that. 

The people in the Democratic establishment don’t. They think they’re living in a city that requires the approval of the monied class to fund development. They fall back on people with well-known names and older celebrities as if they – and not the young people in pubs and bodegas – are the city’s future.

I don’t live in New York City – I live north and west, in a place that’s trying its damnedest to be nothing like New York City. But because the people who live in the ‘burbs often depend on the city, they resent it. 

That’s all crystallized in the congestion pricing debate. Nobody around here wants to pay $15 to drive south of 60th Street in Manhattan, and they see a toll for doing that as a violation of their privilege to use their car wherever the hell they want.

People who live in the congestion pricing zone love it. There’s less traffic, making the streets safer to cross. There’s less noise and pollution. Less horn honking. Buses run faster. Ambulances have fewer obstacles.

Mamdani seems to stand for ideas like that. He wants to find a way to make bus service free and faster. 

He supports the idea of collective city-run supermarkets – not, as residents of Park Slope in Brooklyn know, a completely novel idea. This way, those who are less affluent don’t have to pay the gouged prices you can find at a Morton Williams or Gristedes – supermarket chains you and your wallet should be grateful aren’t in your area.

Mamdani’s win has shaken up New York politics and has the TV talking heads chattering. It has Republicans laser focused on demonizing him in order to get one of its longshots to squeak through. And it has the national Democrats in a quandary – do we embrace or ignore this guy?

So here are four thoughts:

— TRUMP: If you don’t think Mamdani’s win has something to do with Trump, you aren’t paying attention. 

This is absolutely New York Democrats wanting not to feel powerless in the fight against a dictatorship. This is absolutely an entire segment of the populace saying that we’re giving up on trying to triangulate against Trump, let’s take the stupid bastard on.

Trump knows it. He went after Mamdani in one of those whatever-he-calls-a-Truth-Social posts. 

Good. Let’s take the freakin’ gloves off.

— THE MIDDLE EAST: When I was young, there was a beer commercial highlighting New York’s diversity. Each had a tagline – for instance, for Italians, it would be “In New York City, where there are more than Italians than in the whole of Naples, more people drink Rheingold…”

For Jewish New Yorkers, it was “In New York City, where there are more Jews than in the whole of Israel, more people drink Rheingold…”

That was true back then. It’s not now, but New York City is as great as it is in part because of Jewish influence. New Yorkers schlep, they buy tchotchkes, they eat knishes – and all 8 million of them know what those phrases mean.

So Israel is a big issue here, much more so than in any other locality in the U.S. and maybe the world.

Mamdani is Muslim. That’s the background to the fact that he doesn’t support what the Netanyahu government has done in Gaza. He didn’t dance around it. He made one unfortunate comment that gave opponents ammunition to say he’s antisemitic.

He’s not. Opposing Netanyahu and what’s happened in Gaza is not anti-Israel. As I said last week – and stand by – no one has done as much to reignite antisemitism in the world as Benjamin Netanyahu.

I suspect Mamdani will be more assertive about supporting Israeli’s right to exist as much as he supports the Palestinians’ right to self-determination – he kind of mumbled that in his appearance of “The Late Show with Stephen Colbert” this week. 

Importantly, Mamdani garnered a lot of support from Jewish voters who are as heartsick about Gaza as they are about what Hamas did to kids and the elderly in October 2023. And his collaboration with one of his opponents who is Jewish, city comptroller Brad Lander, is meant to show that Mamdani will work with others to make the city a more affordable place to live.

THE DEVIL (aka SOCIALISM): Americans are conditioned to believe socialism is evil. It’s something the wealthiest among us have pushed since the Gilded Age. 

In particular, because they take on the mantle of being “socialist,” communist states such as the Soviet Union and China are what are sold as being the outcome of turning toward socialism.

That’s not right. At all. We already have some vestiges of socialism. Defense contractors and farmers receive subsidies from the federal government. Most public transportation is run by local government agencies.

That’s not going to stop Mamdani’s opponents from conjuring images of empty store shelves and fleeing businesses if he’s elected.

But the real socialism Mamdani proposes is best seen in his plans for small businesses. He wants the city to foster small businesses – provide subsidies, cut fees and fines, offer mentoring programs to get new enterprises going.

That is what people want.

New Yorkers may have swallowed hard and realized they’re socialists after all. Now those who can’t stand that idea – think hedge fund managers and other moguls – need to decide if they want to do without being in the city. 

If so, here’s my thought: Don’t let the limo door hit you on the way out.

DEMOCRATS: We’re now five-plus months into the dark world of Trumpdom II. Sternly worded letters, lawsuits, those endless fund-raising e-mails haven’t done much to make the Democratic party more palatable to the people who rejected it last November. For all of Trump’s plunge in polling, there’s been no political coalescing force.

Maybe Mamdani is the answer. But not in the way Democrats like to think.

The lazy thing would be to think the country is ready for a turn left as exemplified by Mamdani. And it does seem as though New York City might be ready for that after years of being run by supposedly business friendly types: Rudy Giuliani, Mike Bloomberg and Eric Adams.

But what Mamdani did was tap into what New Yorkers want for their city. His little ads were entertaining – watch the one about Halalinflation for a sense of what really matters. 

Instead of preaching from a hill, Mamdani and his supporters traveled the city and understood the problems. And that’s what Democrats around the country need to do.

They do not need to mimic Mamdani’s policy ideas. They need to listen first and then adopt a plan of action that fits the community.

It might very well be more conservative. People in western Pennsylvania or Scottsdale or northern Minnesota might have their own unique issues that require action.

Listen and respond. Get a plan together. Adapt to your constituency. Be smart and engaged about it. No knee-jerk, one-size-fits-all solutions. I love New York, but I don’t think central Wisconsin should be a rural version of it.

In the midst of 100-degree heat and the casual “let’s lob a few bombs into Iran” during the past week, Mamdani’s primary win seems like a moment to cheer. It will certainly make for a little brightness among the gloom – especially if he can further build his coalition from now until November.

favorites://
Standard
Uncategorized

FIGHTING THE ALL-OR-NOTHING COALITION

Baby boomers – that includes me – screwed the pooch.

We talked a good game when we were young. We were going to change the world. We were going to make it fairer. Make love, not war. War is not healthy for children, etc. The arc of the universe is long and bends toward justice, right?

All that stuff.

But for all the education we received at a much better price than other generations, for all the protests and clever music and revolutionary art and tech savvy, we bombed on two of the most important things we could have done.

One is immigration.

Maybe I’m naive, but this is not a hard problem to solve. And, in fact, reasonable politicians of both parties tried several times.

America needs immigrants. As “Hamilton” infers, they get tough jobs done. Sometimes without the credit they deserve. But they do.

But we also need to be careful. That’s the hangover from 9/11. People coming into this country intending to kill us. We need to prevent that.

Still, it is doesn’t seem intractable. Figure out a system that makes citizenship attainable over time and let people come in. Keep tabs on them. If they’re lost, you’ve got a problem – but most of the people who’ve crossed our borders want to live peaceably in the United States.

The other thing we messed up is the Middle East. In particular, Israel.

For its entire 77+ year history, Israel and its Jewish population have faced hostility surrounding it. I couldn’t imagine what it’s like to live in a country without a moment’s peace ever – although I fear we’re learning now.

The Middle East doesn’t seem that difficult. Israel gets a homeland for a Jewish state. Palestinians get someplace that they run themselves. Anybody breaks the peace, everybody in the world comes down on them.

OK, that’s a little simplistic. But it’s ridiculous that a part of the world special to more than a billion people – Jews, Christians and Muslims – should be a tinder box instead of a pilgrimage destination.

Reasonable people see that.

The problem here is that despite all the efforts made to sort this out – Camp David and Oslo among the more successful – there’s no rest for the hostility weary.

And the reason is this: For all the billions of the world who want peace in the region, there’s a de facto coalition that doesn’t.

At the center of the coalition are two forces that can’t stand each other: Hamas and its radical allies in the region, and Benjamin Netanyahu and the Gulf States on the region.

Yeah, these two sides – and the partners who back them – are eager to fight to the death – preferably the death of guys they’re fighting. These partners include – on one side or the other – Iran, Russia, Saudi Arabia and the Trump administration.

So when those of us who think that two states – Israel and some formation of a Palestinian government – are the only possible peaceful solution, these two sides that hate each other coalesce to stop that idea cold.

Benjamin Netanyahu saw Hamas’ horrific attack on Israeli civilians in October 2023 as an opportunity to divert attention from the criminal investigations he faced and rally forces against any kind of peace deal with Palestinians. 

And by being heavy-handed in dealing with the Palestinians living in Gaza, he gave a rallying point to Hamas. 

So whenever some idiot throws a brick with the words “Free Palestine” through a synagogue window, know that Netanyahu would rather you do that than shout the words “two states.”

Because these people are an all-or-nothing coalition. They want you cleared out of the way so that they can get on with the ultimate battle for control of the holiest piece of land in the world.

There’s a solution, but it’s not going to happen. Not now, anyway.

Last weekend, millions of Americans came together to tell Donald Trump he’s a jerk. To battle his desire to be some kind of king or dictator. 

What if large numbers of people around the world joined together with most of the world’s Jews and Muslims and said they won’t support anything but a two-state solution to this problem?

You see, Joe Biden’s failure here was worrying that he wouldn’t have the support to challenge Netanyahu’s wag-the-dog campaign. And worrying that if he didn’t give full-throated support to Netanyahu, he’d be accused of abetting Hamas – the terrorists who kidnapped children and elderly people, and held them for nearly two years or killed them.

The problem is that Americans are so distracted by what Trump has done in the past five months that they’re just overwhelmed by BS. And as awful as things can get in the Middle East – Trump is itching to drop bombs on Tehran to prove he still has a cock – Americans are besieged. By these idiotic tariffs, the potential gutting of their healthcare, the possibility that no one will come help them when hurricanes batter our shore, and the grabbing of neighbors off the street by secret police.

Maybe it seems as though I got away from my original point – that we, as baby boomers, failed.

I didn’t. We should have solved this problem. We had chances all the way into the Obama administration. We couldn’t muster the will or imagination to beat these people back, just as we couldn’t muster the will or imagination to overcome the forces that profit from trying to deport undocumented immigrants.

We didn’t do it. And now, the all-or-nothing coalition holds the reins, ready for the dogfights they’ve wanted for years.

Shame on them. Shame on us.

favorites://
Standard
Uncategorized

OUTRAGE, INC.

We kinda knew, prior to January 20, what would happen.

Trump put together a collection of some of the worst people who’ve ever lived in this country. And that’s saying something – if their heirs donated to Trump’s campaign, Benedict Arnold, Nathan Bedford Forrest and Al Capone would have been pardoned and/or given jobs.

This collection of pond scum set out with a plan. Go after as many stable, peaceful, prosperous, honorable and – here’s the key word – diverse elements of American life that don’t support their warped view of America. Sow chaos, pick fights with entities that have been as removed from the title “enemy” as you can imagine.

Harvard. Canada. Childhood vaccinations. Bruce Springsteen. Solar energy. Women professionals. School kids of color.

And, of course, Los Angeles.

Now, to be clear, L.A. is not even close to being my favorite city in the United States. It’s not even in the top ten. Seven-lane freeways are an abomination. The Dodgers abandoned the good people of Brooklyn. I’m actually surprised there’s something they consider a downtown.

But there are people who love L.A. Not just Randy Newman. They like the quirkiness of having lots of different cultures mesh together into a spectacle for the senses – music, art, food, clothing, language. Millions of people who work hard, struggle to put food on their families’ tables and enjoy the occasional kimchi taco.

Which is why the city is one of the hubs of resistance to what Trump’s cuckoo coterie wants. Because it is, with Miami and New York, a center of immigrant culture in the United States, it is an easy target. And why so many Angelinos are out in the streets trying to stop ICE, the American Gestapo, from its heinous raids.

Destroying the immigrant idea that built this damn country is their touchstone. MAGAts act as though their families sprouted from the heartland soil and don’t have a long boat trip or plane ride in their DNA.

What they’ve been terrified of is the fact that the United States has gotten closer to becoming a majority minority country. That some coalition of Black, Latino, Asian and indigenous people will soon make up 50.01% of the population. 

And they think that coalition, should it so choose, would wreak on strictly Caucasian people some of the despicable acts that Caucasians inflicted on them since arriving here. Slavery, mass deportation and exclusion acts can go both ways.

For now, the question is how to combat these manufactured outrages, the ones Trump and the gang conjured as he stewed after Joe Biden beat him handily in 2020.

Well, one thing might be to keep reminding him that he lost in 2020. Trump has been plotting revenge against the whole country – not just the states that didn’t support him – since then. Some 81 million of us rejected him and the 74 million who did vote for him didn’t do enough to ensure his return. Even winning last year didn’t make up for that loss, that failure to adore him. 

But rehashing 2020 is hardly a solution to the problem we face now.

As far as Los Angeles goes, continuing the protests, even in the face of the world’s strongest military, is paramount. What’s also true is that the protests can’t be violent – Trump wants nothing more than to bully protesters and show off the force he believes he controls.

Making the people behind the ICE masks pariahs – actually, that would speed up what the rest of their life is going to be like – is one course of action. In Los Angeles and other cities, shun these people. Their money is no good in your store or they need to identify themselves fully in order to use their credit cards. 

I thought about whether or not any family members of ICE agents should be targets. Normally, I would find that heinous. But these are the people who have taken children from their parents and parents from their children. They’ve raided graduations. They’ve raided the legal proceedings that immigrants are required to attend. 

It would be interesting to see how they would feel about being on the other side of their bile.

But then we would be stooping to their level. We would become the same kind of unthinking, heartless being that is defiling the streets of our cities. So leave their families alone – just pick on the ICEes.

This Saturday, June 14, Trump is orchestrating a military parade through Washington. He’ll tell you it’s to celebrate the Army’s 250th anniversary. It’s actually to celebrate his 79th birthday. 

It’s easy to say that you shouldn’t go. But I suspect somebody is going to do something to disrupt it. In any case, there are protests around the nation to counter this massive ego trip. Join, if you don’t already have plans.

My preferred course has always been to come up with a strong positive alternative to Trumpism. A plan that would actually make people’s lives better – accelerating a lot of the ways the world has improved in my lifetime. Promoting clean energy and improved transportation. Health care for all. Support for families no matter how they’re constituted.

But Trump has the money and the manipulated Congressional support to let his mass despicabilities take over the agenda. People are hurting. 

We need to throw sand into the outrage machine.

Standard
Uncategorized

NO, I DON’T FEEL SORRY FOR THEM

Can you imagine what it’s like to be an ICE agent in June 2025?

Probably not, because I imagine the people who read this come equipped with compassion, intelligence, scruples, understanding of democracy and other attributes of positive humanity.

But we are people who see that all of us are real human beings, with imperfections and such. So I guess, intellectually, we know that the ICE agents we see committing these despicable acts against vulnerable immigrants are, uh, people.

So what do you think it takes to be part of the American Gestapo?

There are, according to the Department of Homeland Security, about 20,000 people who work in various capacities for ICE. That’s one in every 17,500 Americans.

Of course, that doesn’t include the local law enforcement types who want to show they can be among the big federal boys.

I can’t imagine anybody who works at ICE was particularly good at civics in school – assuming, of course, they went to school. Maybe that’s a big assumption. They missed the classes about the Constitution – or the classes they had focused only on the Second Amendment to the exclusion of the other 26 (or 27 if you count the Equal Rights Amendment).

When confronted with the concept of due process applying to all persons – you know, that Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment stuff – their brains find it difficult to grasp the concept. So they ignore it – it’s probably easier than actually reading less than 100 words – which might stretch the extent of their vocabulary.

Being fashion forward probably disqualifies you from ICE. You’ve got to wear those drab ersatz military-style outfits as befits wannabe warriors. After bemoaning mask-wearing during the pandemic as freedom-infringing, you have to wear a black one during a long day of scooping up kids and mothers.

Most people in legitimate law enforcement go after what we used to think of as real crimes such as stealing money. That was, of course, before Trump pardoned people convicted of fraud because they or their families like him.

But those legitimate law enforcers are usually pretty proud of who they are and what they do. They’re thought of as brave and even-handed.

So they put stickers in their car saying they’re cops. They show up at festivals and parades. They’re the helpers Mr. Rogers told kids to look for in times of trouble.

What if those kids in trouble listened to Mr. Rogers and ran up to an ICE agent? I imagine they’d be cursing the nicest man in history in their native language from the friendly confines of a South Sudan internment camp.

On Career Day at school, the kids of legitimate law enforcement officers show up with their Moms and Dads in uniform.

What do ICE agent parents do at Career Day? Show up in their khakis, shades and masks? Demonstrate what it feels like to experience a flash grenade? Tell the kids to make sure they have all their papers in order – and take a few with them if they look a little scared?

Assuming that people who work for ICE are family men and the occasional woman. 

I can’t imagine they go to normal bars and church socials to meet people. Who wants to go out with somebody who might send you to El Salvador if the relationship goes sour?

That’s why there’s a lot of thought that ICE agents are incels – involuntary celebates. That makes some sense.

Unless, of course, there’s some app ICE agents use for meeting suitable mates. You swipe left and someone who loves to be dominated shows up as the mate of your dreams. Those handcuffs and twist ties aren’t just for lawn mowers, hamburger cooks and housekeepers. Good times.

And here’s the part about working for ICE that is going to make it unique:

You see, one day, this madness will end. You and I are determined to make that happen. We’ll be about the business of repairing the damage that Trump, Musk, the saps in Congress, the Christian Nationalists and your neighbor with the “Daddy’s Home” flag (I’ve actually seen that!) have done.

These ICE agents will still be of employment age. Except who is going to hire them? An employer and co-workers will always know that so-and-so grabbed defenseless people, hurled them into vans, denied them their rights, and sent them away from the lives they peaceably created and the people they helped.

Not to mention all the days these people will miss from work for testifying in the lawsuits that will brought against them by the hundreds. It’s hard to be a security guard at Walmart when you’re in court four days a week.

Normally, I have a soft spot for people with troubled lives. There but for the grace of God, et cetera.

Except I know I would never betray other human beings and the ideals of American democracy. Not for any amount of money – including the $40,000 bonuses Republicans are trying to give them.

So do I feel bad for these people? Nah.

Do they deserve all the opprobrium they will face for the rest of their lives?

Absolutely.

Standard
Uncategorized

WHO KNOWS WHAT GOOD LURKS IN THE HEART OF OUR COUNTRY? THE SHADOW MIGHT

When he isn’t busy pardoning fraudsters whose family members donate money to him, Donald Trump has the wrecking crew he assembled as a cabinet working to destroy this country.

Commercially exploiting federal land. Denying the effectiveness of vaccination in combatting disease and illness. Pissing off our traditional allies. Attempting to destroy one of the world’s most prestigious universities.

It’s like what the team the arch-villain in a superhero movie conjures. Except I don’t see any Bruce Waynes or Clark Kents in the neighborhood.

And the Democratic Party, the force best suited in this moment to fight back, is engaged in circular firing squad mode.

But Elissa Slotkin, the recently elected junior senator from Michigan, has one idea that might start to turn things around.

Slotkin suggests that the Democrats form a shadow Cabinet – a team of experts that mimics the roles of the actual team of horribles Trump assembled.

While a shadow Cabinet would have none of the enforcement power of its MAGA stooge counterpart, it would help give the Democratic Party something it needs desperately: a plan.

The “secretaries” would help to develop policies – in the same way the party develops a platform just before the quadrennial convention. Those policies would serve as alternatives to what Trump and his henchpeople are doing to America’s government and image.

For instance, with the Republicans seemingly determined to undermine Medicaid and strip it away from millions of people who need it, a shadow Health and Human Services Secretary could propose an expansion of the Affordable Care Act – aka Obamacare. That would further reduce medical costs for all Americans and stand in stark contrast.

Put that out there and see what happens. There’s a chance it could force the MAGA idiots to reconsider their plan – they’ll argue it’s socialism or whatever, but they’ll feel some pressure. As opposed to now, when all they’re hearing is that what they’re doing is bad.

Come up with an alternative that someone articulate can sell – and it doesn’t look like “he said, she said” politics as usual.

That’s the thing. The Democrats have an advantage in that most of the people who speak as leaders of the party can do so in complete sentences. From Barack Obama to AOC to Pete Buttigieg to Tim Walz, the party knows how to communicate effectively.

But a shadow Cabinet should not contain people who might be running for the White House in 2028. Or, obviously Obama – unlike the Republicans, Democrats take Constitutional term limits seriously.

Not sure exactly who that is just yet. But it could be AOC, Buttigieg, maybe Walz, Gretchen Whitmer, Gavin Newsom or Kamala Harris.

That doesn’t mean there isn’t talent to make the Democrats’ case.

Politico recently gave 21 names for a Democratic shadow Cabinet. Some of them are outright silly. Ben Stein is a hardcore Republican and I’d bet money he voted for Trump; just because his character in “Ferris Bueller’s Day Off” bemoans tariffs doesn’t mean he’ll stand up against them in real life. He’s also 80 years old.

And Jon Stewart, while incredibly potent as an advocate for veterans, is much more effective as a nonpartisan lampooner than serving as a party spokesman.

But some of the other names are interesting. 

Letitia James, New York’s attorney general, has stood up to Trump before and even won a civil fraud case against him and his company. She is a no-nonsense law enforcement advocate and – as a native Brooklynite – isn’t afraid to speak her mind.

Samantha Power knows how foreign aid makes our country safer. She headed USAID when it was giving money to fight disease and hunger around the world – something Trump and Marco Rubio, his Secretary of State, feel is too “woke.” Having her out front as a defender of America’s generosity and compassion is a visual I’d be proud to see.

However, the personalities aren’t important. As I’ve said since January 20, the Democrats can’t just be against Trump. They have to stand for something more than returning to the status quo. They need to understand that people are frustrated with the direction of the country and want their lives to be easier.

Joe Biden understood that, but his limitations made that hard to sell – he couldn’t go to a lot of college campuses or big stadium rallies the way Barack Obama could. The Democrats need a plan of action and a bunch of articulate leaders of all varieties to go out and spell out a better future – and then watch Trump stew as those plans catch fire with the public.

It’ll take some work. But it’ll be worth it. Often bad things lurk in shadows, but they provide shade from a burning sun. And right now, the America we love is getting scorched – a little Democratic shadowing could help.

Standard
Uncategorized

IN THEIR MEMORY

Naphtali Daggett took over as president pro tempore of Yale University in 1766. He succeeded Thomas Clap, who seemed to piss off everybody in New Haven and the colony of Connecticut.

Daggett never held the full-time title of president when he resigned in 1777, but he remained part of the Yale community. So when the British attacked New Haven in 1779, the 52-year-old divinity professor took on a new title: sniper. He picked off Redcoats until his capture.

The British felt no need to defer to Daggett. They forced him on a long march to West Haven, bayoneting him along the way. 

Daggett never recovered, dying in 1780. His son, Ebenezer died a year later after contracting smallpox fighting in Virginia.

Everybody remembers the Battle of Fort McHenry in the War of 1812 because a lawyer, Francis Scott Key, wrote lyrics to a song about it.

But Frederick Hall spent the night of September 10, 1814 in a ditch surrounding the fort, tasked with preventing the British from getting through. Although his fellow soldiers knew him by a different name – William Williams (apparently, that old New York DJ wasn’t the first to claim that name). 

There was a good reason for the identity change. Earlier in the year, Hall ran away from the plantation where he was born and enslaved. Even though the British promised freedom to slaves who helped them, Hall signed up to defend Baltimore.

Hall/Williams endured the 25-hour bombardment. He and the 38th Infantry watched the rockets’ red glare probably in terror – an unidentified woman helping out was torn in half by one of the projectiles.

What Hall/Williams couldn’t survive was tuberculosis. He died of it in March 1815, one of four American fatalities in the battle that gave us the National Anthem.

William Watson had it going. In his late 30s, he was the speaker of the Maryland House of Delegates, one of two bodies in the state legislature.

He also had a military bent and was a captain in the state’s 5th Regiment.

When the Mexican-American War broke out, the governor promoted Watson to lieutenant colonel and sent him south to join Gen. Zachary Taylor. From Texas, the army marched to Monterrey, Mexico.

It was there that Watson and the regiment fought house to house. First, his horse was shot out from under him. Then he got hit. 

Fifty-seven years later, a monument to Watson and those who fought in Mexico was dedicated near a park in Baltimore. The ceremony was led by Watson’s daughter, born the day he died.

Thanks to the movie “Glory,” the heroism of the 54th Massachusetts Infantry is known to millions.

One of the real soldiers who took part in the siege of Fort Wagner in South Carolina was James Henry Gooding. He was born a slave in 1838, but someone – most likely his father – purchased his freedom as a child. He eventually became a whaler, working out of New Bedford, Massachusetts, where he married in early 1863.

He didn’t spend much time with his wife. Just before the wedding, President Lincoln signed the Emancipation Proclamation – and Gooding enlisted a month later.

Gooding actually survived Fort Wagner – as we saw in “Glory,” much of the 54th Massachusetts didn’t. But in early 1864, he was wounded in the thigh in Olustee, Florida, and captured by the Confederates. He died in the notorious Andersonville, Georgia, prison that summer and is buried there.

His war letters – including one to Lincoln demanding that soldiers receive equal pay regardless of race – were published more than a century later.

Newell Rising sounds like one of those young men who has trouble figuring it all out.

At age 27, after working as a mold maker in an iron works and a clerk for an insurance agency, Rising went to the Brooklyn Navy Yard in 1896 and enlisted.

He was first assigned to the U.S.S. Vermont, but soon moved to the U.S.S. Maine. His job was coal passer, lifting 140-pound buckets of coal to the firemen keeping the ship running. He also had to clean coal dust from strainers and other not-particularly-pleasant-sounding tasks.

Rising was aboard the Maine on February 12, 1898 when it suffered an explosion while on a tense mission in Havana, as the United States and Spain faced off over Cuba.

In all likelihood, the coal was responsible for the blast. But William Randolph Hearst preferred a different theory – that the Spanish set it off. Thus began the Spanish-American War, which led to the U.S. gaining territory in Puerto Rico and the Philippines.

Newell Rising’s body was never identified. What’s presumed to be his remains – and those of 228 other sailors and marines – are buried at the Maine Memorial in Arlington National Cemetery. There’s also a marker commemorating Rising at Summerfield Park in his hometown of Port Chester, New York.

The New York Yankees finished in seventh place in the American League in 1914. 

One of the team’s players that year was Tom Burr – but that’s kind of stretching it. Burr was put in as a defensive replacement against the Washington Nationals on April 21. He played one inning in center field.

That is the sum total of his MLB career. He didn’t get to bat, a la Moonlight Graham in “Field of Dreams.”

Barr went back to college at Williams, then found his way to France when World War I broke out. After serving as an ambulance driver, he signed up for the aviation corps.

Exactly 30 days before the war ended, Burr was flying over France when his plane collided with another aircraft. His body was recovered 12 days later.

Burr was one of eight major leaguers killed in what was once called the Great War.

Joseph Takata worked as a clerk for Castle & Cooke, the conglomerate that developed Hawaii beginning in the 19th century.

Less than a month before Pearl Harbor, the Nisei – second-generation Japanese – man was inducted into the military and assigned close to his Honolulu home. He got married in the spring of ’42 as he began his tour throughout the world.

That tour took him to Italy, of all places. He was part of the 100th Infantry Battalion – an all-Nisei unit, some of whose soldiers had family members in relocation camps because they were Japanese in origin.

The 100th – and the 442nd Regimental Combat Team – got stuck with the brutal task of freeing Italy from fascism. On September 29, 1943, at Salerno, Takata was killed in combat – the first, but far from the last, Nisei to give his life for a country that didn’t respect him.

He was not forgotten. Every year, a ceremony is held in September at the National Memorial Ceremony of the Pacific at Punchbowl to honor Takata and his comrades.

Despite being born in Evanston, Illinois, the home of Northwestern University, Thomas Baldwin Jr. chose to attend Cornell, where he studied architectural engineering. It was the family legacy – his father worked as an architect for the Crane Co.

Baldwin was 25 years old when his was called to active duty as the Korean War broke out. 

About six months later, Baldwin was wounded as American-led U.N. forces faced down the last major offensive mounted by the North Koreans and their Chinese allies. It either wasn’t that serious an injury or he just talked his way back to his unit.

In any event, a few days after returning, Baldwin was killed on what now would be North Korean territory.

He was buried in Maryland. His parents, who outlived him by more than 20 years, are buried there with him.

Yesterday would have been Paul F. Doyon’s 77th birthday. Unfortunately, last Sunday was the 55th anniversary of his death.

Doyon was a lance corporal in the U.S. Marines. He was from Ipswich, in the northeast corner of Massachusetts.

On May 21, 1967, Doyon’s company in the Third Marine Amphibious Force was in action in Quang Tri province in South Vietnam. He would have been 19 three days later.

Doyon was the first resident of Ipswich killed in Vietnam. To honor him, the community voted to name its relatively new elementary school after him – it wasn’t the one he would have attended when he was of age. The vote was 99-98, which says a little something about the frictions the Vietnam War created throughout America.

It is still Paul F. Doyon Elementary School. There’s a picture of him in the lobby

Meredeth Holland would be about my age right now.

She grew up around Corpus Christi, Texas, with a love of the sea. She studied marine resource management at Texas A&M, but found that going out on survey expeditions made her seasick.

So Holland did the logical thing. She became a firefighter, then got involved in investigating fires for insurers, moving to the San Francisco Bay area.

She also enlisted in the Army Reserve at the age of 34. She got into the military for the benefits, fearing that she might otherwise grow old and live on the streets.

Holland married Hugh Hvolboll in December 2005, just after she learned that her unit was being deployed to Afghanistan. They had known each other for years, but thought it important to get hitched before she went into danger.

Her job in Afghanistan wasn’t supposed to involve combat. She was part of a campaign to help educate kids – especially girls – gifting backpacks to them. 

But on September 8, 2006, Holland was the gunner on a humvee rolling through downtown Kabul. A suicide bomber smashed his car into the military vehicle, killing Holland. At 52, she was the oldest female fatality of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.

There is no final resting place for Meredith Holland – unless you count the water near her two hometowns. Her husband ran a fireworks company. Some of her ashes went up in a fireworks display over Corpus Christi, the rest in one over San Francisco Bay on what would have been the couple’s first anniversary.

Memorial Day has become big parades and civil ceremonies. Placing a wreath at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier in Arlington. Furniture sales and baseball teams wearing camo outfits.

We know that thousands of Americans have lost their lives in our 249-year history.

But what’s also been lost is the idea that these people weren’t just Risk board pieces. Or easily wrapped into one giant flag.

They were people with lives and loves. Dreams of careers and even careers themselves. Families sometimes. Troubled and privileged pasts. Ex-slaves. 

They were individuals. And they gave up that individuality for the idea that this country, for all its faults, is a land of promise. They didn’t revel in victory – the notion of victory in war as if it’s a sporting event is disgusting, in case Trump or one of his moronic adherents reads this. 

They just served their country because it was what they thought they were supposed to do.

When you get to Monday, try to think not of the collective sacrifice but the individual ones. The lives interrupted and the courage it takes to endure that. The loved ones missing someone so badly it hurts.

I feel privileged to have gotten to know the stories of the ten people above. May their memories be a blessing.

favorites://
Standard
Uncategorized

HELLO, YOU MUST BE GOING

The United States is co-hosting the 2025 Men’s World Cup soccer championship,, beginning next month, along with Canada and Mexico.

I’m not a soccer fan. I don’t care what the world thinks and I don’t care how funny “Ted Lasso” is. It’s a boring sport. My father categorized a sport he didn’t like as an “eye test.” That works for me.

There was one thing I did like about the World Cup being in the United States —  was that a world of people with a low threshold of excitement were going to fly to New York, Los Angeles and Boston – among other places. They were going to spend money in our hotels, eat at our restaurants, buy tchotchkes from people on street corners, maybe go to the theater or see live music. 

It was going to be great getting easily entertained people to part with their euros, pesos, yen, won or whatever.

Not any more.

Americans somehow chose Donald Trump as president. The rest of the world didn’t. And as much as they enjoy seeing guys wearing their nations’ colors running around kicking a ball and occasionally putting it in a net, the people of the world aren’t looking for the hassle the Trump troupe seems hellbent on inflicting.

This was expressed most clearly last week by the dolt who is vice president, J.D. Vance. 

“Of course everyone is welcome to come and see this wonderful event,” Vance said. “We want them to come, we want them to celebrate, we want them to watch the games.”

There’s always a but with these people.

“But when the time is up we want them to go home,” he added, warning them not to overstay their visas.

Successful tourism makes you feel welcome. My family went to London last summer and I felt welcomed and appreciated by everyone I encountered. Their patience with a dense old American was exemplary.

Contrast that with what we’re telling people coming to this country in 2025. Sure you can show up for your sports event, but then get the hell out of here.

As if anything we’re doing is encouraging people to stay.

The fact is that the U.S. was poised to benefit from a strengthening world economy. New York City, perhaps the No. 1 destination for international tourists, was expecting a surge in visitors – an especially welcome development for a city whose theater industry generates significant revenue.

Now, forget it. The wacko rhetoric of Trump and his henchmen. The videos of people suspected – not convicted, mind you – of being in this country without documentation being ambushed by ICE and police collaborators. 

That’s not what people traveling want. They can watch the World Cup from a pub in their home country and not worry about abduction, harassment or just plain stupidity.

It’s a shame. We have a fantastic country that we should share with the world. We have spectacular national parks, theme parks that are the envy of all, magnificent art and architecture.

None of this is of value to Trump or the rest of the Republican idiots. They think what makes America great is a perverted value of strength.’

In the process, American tourism will lose billions of dollars from people who are too afraid or too angry to put up with the nonsense we’ve been dealing with since January 20.

Trump will revel in the World Cup when it begins on June 11. He’ll show up at some stadium, probably one in a place where he’s not wildly unpopular – Dallas or Miami. And he’ll sit in some luxury box and wave majestically before he leaves at the 45-minute intermission.

We’ll have to deal with this crap again in 2028, when the Olympics come to Los Angeles. Unless the situation in this country is so bad that it would be a colossal mistake to hold the games here.

For some reason, that doesn’t seem so far-fetched.

Standard
Uncategorized

UNCLE SAM WANTS YOU!

My biggest worry when I was 18 is no American’s biggest worry in 2025.

It was the draft. The Vietnam War was on – and I was one of my many peers who thought Vietnam was a stupid, evil idea.

And not just because being drafted to go to Vietnam would screw up my life plans. The idea of dying in a war about as far away from New York as possible, for no reason that I thought worthwhile, was about as pathetic a thing as I could imagine.

The draft was abolished just in time for me to miss it. I actually went through the lottery in 1973 and came up with 89 – out of 365. Those odds wouldn’t have been good. 

So I never served in the all-volunteer U.S. military.

Over the years, I’ve grown to respect and admire the men and women who serve because they believe it is what Americans are supposed to do. That was wrong in Vietnam and Iraq, as history has proven. But it reflects a love of country that seems honorable from here in 2025.

The idea of doing something for your country before you begin a lifelong career seems to be lost on most young Americans. It was tarnished by the Vietnam experience; many of the parents and grandparents of today’s teenagers are adamant that their kids not serve in the military, especially involuntarily.

But what if the draft wasn’t only for the military.

What if all Americans, by the time they turn 23, were required to perform some sort of national service. It could be in the military – there are millions of people who are inclined to serve that way.

But it could also be for purposes that don’t require guns. National service could be used as a conservation corps to maintain national parks. It could be used to help convert commercial buildings into affordable housing. It could be a way to teach underserved kids to read, to feed senior citizens and veterans.

It would be almost an extra education year that would come with some sort of renumeration. 

Why is this a good idea?

Three reasons.

First, it would put the energy and imagination of our nation’s young people toward solving problems that just never seem to go away.

Young adults would not do dangerous jobs. They would get some leeway in choosing the service they perform, much as those who sign up for the military now pick the branch of service they want.

In the process, they would challenge the way we do things and improve on them. They would be a force for the change they want to see in the world, taking responsibility for it in a way that getting a job out of school wouldn’t.

Secondly, it would give different things to different people.

For those coming from underprivileged backgrounds, a national service requirement would provide training and guidance that they’re not getting in school. It would give them an opportunity to find something on which to build a career.

As for the privileged, working a year in public service would show them how the things they do affect society on an interpersonal level. Doctors, lawyers, bankers, among others, often don’t understand how their decisions play with the people of a community. This would be a chance to see it at ground level.

When the draft existed, it was easy to duck if you had the resources. Example No. 1 is the current occupant of the Oval Office, who despite attending military school managed to get out of induction because of supposed bone spurs in his feet. (This is a man who his doctor currently describes as 6’4″ and 224 pounds, so his medical history might be questionable.)

This draft would not be duckable. If you have bone spurs, you can still work as a clerk in a food distribution warehouse. You can help sort stuff cleaned off a beach.

Finally, a national service requirement would provide something that’s been missing from the United States for a long time.

A sense of empathy for the other people in our country.

There’s this nonsense that stratifies the coasts from the interior, recent immigrants from people whose families came here generations ago, blue states from red states.

A national service requirement would force young people to interact with other young people from around the nation. New Yorkers have no concept what rural Wisconsin is like – Wisconsin farmers have all kinds of Fox News-induced ideas about the terrors of Manhattan.

In World War II, getting to know fellow Americans worked to create the most powerful fighting force in history – one that defeated fascism around the world. And that was with the kind of discriminatory laws that prevented everyone from taking part.

A national service requirement might help stop the nonsense that we’ve seen in this country this year. 

It’s probably never going to happen. But it’s an idea worth considering.

favorites://
Standard
Uncategorized

I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE. JUST NOT TO THE FLAG.

The Republican who represents my Congressional district held a town hall meeting this week. 

Perhaps even more than other districts, this is a swing. Mike Lawler, with the help of more than a million dollars of Elon Musk’s money, held on to the seat he first won in the GOP sweep of 2022. 

So the nearly half of voters who didn’t vote for him – and even a percentage of those who did – were pretty damn pissed about what’s gone down since January 20.

How pissed?

Here’s the first few paragraphs of Nicholas Fandos’ account in The New York Times:

No one was expecting a love fest when Representative Mike Lawler, Republican of New York, faced constituents in his suburban swing district on Sunday night. Still, even he seemed surprised by the night’s first clash — over the Pledge of Allegiance.

“Please tell me you’re not objecting to the Pledge of Allegiance,” Mr. Lawler asked incredulously after some members of the audience inside a high school auditorium audibly groaned when he suggested reciting it.

They acquiesced, and several hundred attendees labored to their feet to say the pledge, but not without indicating why they believed its words had come to ring hollow.

I didn’t attend the meeting at one of the high schools in my school district. I expected my more boisterous neighbors to show up and say pretty much what I would have said about the disaster that is the 47th Presidency of the United States.

But I would not have “labored to my feet” for the Pledge of Allegiance. Because I think you can find the core of what’s wrong with the United States right now in it.

Most of the countries that have traditionally been our allies – Britain, Canada, France, Italy and so on – don’t have a pledge. Their kids don’t start their day trying to say a word similar to “indivisible;” whoever wrote the Pledge – and its authorship is disputed – was not thinking clearly about the hearing and enunciation of elementary school kids.

That wouldn’t be a problem. We’re not those countries – as Archie Bunker said, “We threw the British out of here.” – and so there’s no need to follow their example.

The problem with the Pledge of Allegiance is that it’s only secondary to “the republic.” Its primary focus – and this goes for the National Anthem, too – is the flag.

The first thing is the flag. “I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America.”

The flag. Not the Constitution. Not the laws of our land. Not to the now 340 million of us who actually make up this country, who get kissed off at the end with the words “with liberty and justice for all.”

No. A rectangular cloth of nylon, polyester or cotton – is the thing to which we pledge our allegiance. The material would have been used as a windbreaker or a tablecloth or the flag of Vanuatu. But because it has a pattern of stripes and stars that meet general approval, it deserves our allegiance?

That seems like a lot. And I think the problem is that too many Americans – particularly the ones who support the current president – confuse the flag with what it’s supposed to stand for.

They think its existence is the height of patriotism. They actually say that – every year, some group runs with a flag from West Point to somewhere else before Memorial Day. The promotion of it in our town calls it the most patriotic thing.

It’s the Shroud of Turin of the American experience.

And lost in all this is how we think about each other.

We are supposed to be a nation of laws. We have this great Constitution – if you’ve been reading this blog recently, you’ve joined me in a full reading. And it’s being trampled by Trump and his henchmen because they worship the flag, not the principles that are supposed to guide American democracy.

Hell, they used the flag as a weapon on January 6, 2021. Watch the videos of these MAGA maroons assaulting Capitol Police officers with sharpened flagpoles. They pledged allegiance to the flag – and then betrayed the country it represents.

And then there’s the variations designed to intimidate people they don’t like. The black stars and stripes with the blue stripe in the middle that says I support police, even when they’re beating up people for no reason. The “Blue Lives Matter” answer to “Black Lives Matter.”

It’s not just the pledge – our national anthem is the freaking “Star-Spangled Banner,” about a flag that’s still flying after the Battle of Fort McHenry in Baltimore. No one remembers much about the battle, like how many Americans were killed or how they managed to hold off the British who had just stomped through Washington.

Instead, what they remember is some lyrics a lawyer wrote to a British drinking song about the flag still being there.

No other civilized nation I can think of is as hung up on the flag as the United States.

Various groups have established all these rules on how the flag should be presented. You can’t wear it. God forbid it falls into a puddle or, shudder, touches the ground. You have to burn a flag if it’s worn out, but if you burn it in protest, woe is you.

The things that are sacred to me about the United States of America are the things to which I’ll pledge allegiance.

The rule of law.

Civility. Conducting myself as a responsible citizen.

Kindness.

Appreciation of just how beautiful this land is. Shepherding the land so that fellow Americans appreciate the same things 1,000 years from now.

Honoring those who have served our nation. Not just the military, although it should be held in reverence, but those who have labored to make our states, our cities and our neighborhoods safer and stronger. That includes teachers, firefighters, sanitation workers, and so many others that their omission is going to piss off people. (Sorry!)

And celebration of the people who live in my country. No matter what they look like or who they love or where their families started their American journey.

When the flag is the point, people aren’t. And that leads to the kind of detachment so many Americans seem to have. We’re a nation of indignation because we’ve lost respect for our own people. America isn’t the flag – it’s the people and the laws that protect them.

That’s to whom we should pledge our allegiance.

We did, once.

In 1776, our representatives meeting in Philadelphia approved a document written by a Virginia farmer. It ends this way: “And for the support of this Declaration, with a firm reliance on the protection of divine Providence, we mutually pledge to each other our Lives, our Fortunes and our sacred Honor.”

We should be willing to pledge our lives, our fortunes and our sacred honor mutually – in support of one another – as Americans. Not a flag.

favorites://
Standard
Uncategorized

O SAY, CAN YOU SEE?

I’m not one for performative patriotism.

But recently, I’ve had a lot of thoughts about a performance of the National Anthem I saw.

It was before the start of a Mets game at Citi Field in New York. The day was chilly – the temperature never rose above 47 degrees. At least it was sunny – I sat close to the field and the  sun beating down helped keep things comfortable.

On an aesthetic level, I’ve never been a big fan of “The Star Spangled Banner.” My argument boils down to this – the nation that produced George Gershwin, Duke Ellington, Carole King and Stevie Wonder should not be represented by a Maryland lawyer’s poem sung to the tune of a British drinking song.

The song is hard to sing. It’s a so-so message. And, in the dumb way the United States seems to think of patriotism, it’s about a flag.

(Getting hung up on the flag is also the problem with the Pledge Of Allegiance. That’s a topic for another time.)

Another issue is that the government of the United States has not inspired any fervent love since, oh, noon ET on January 20. The inanity of Trumpism clouds every decent day and exacerbates the lousy ones.

This was particularly true when this anthem was performed. It was five days after the Mets’ home opener against the Toronto Blue Jays, the only Major League Baseball team that makes its home outside this country.

Until 2025, no one gave much thought to the rendition of “O Canada” when a Canadian team showed up in a U.S. stadium. But then Trump, not content with taking a dump on the rest of the world, decided to pick on the best neighbor any country has ever had.

That led to the boos from about a tenth of the crowd. Forget that some young woman is performing before 40,000 people and hearing disdain from about 4,000 people. She’s doing her best, but, yeah, boo anyway. 

I wasn’t shocked by this. But I was not going to follow that wretched display by singing “The Star Spangled Banner” with these slugs. 

So I found what I thought was appropriate- bowing my head as if this were a moment of silence, in memory of what we as Americans have lost because of this stupidity. (It also made me respect, all the more, what Colin Kaepernick did by kneeling – had I stronger knees, I might have thought about it.)

Fast forward five days. It’s only going to be the U.S. anthem at the game on the cold day because the Mets were playing Miami. I get up, remove my hat and bow my head.

And then I hear the anthem.

It was performed by a chorus of students from the Celia Cruz Bronx High School of Music. It is one of the special high schools in the New York City public school system – you need to go through an audition process to get in.

And, for the few who don’t know, it’s named for one of the most influential Latin musicians in U.S.  history. She left Cuba shortly after the revolution and made great music with another renowned Hispanic artist, Tito Puente. Her influence was such that, if you look in your loose change, you might have the quarter with her image that came out last year.

The chorus performed a capella. You had to think about that, because the harmonies created were so lush that they seemed like an orchestra.

What was striking was that these students – from all over New York City and most, but not all of them, kids of color – were putting incredible passion into this rendition. Maybe it was because they wanted to impress thousands of people hearing them. 

But that kind of performance requires more than showing off your musical chops. It was as if they believed they were honoring their home with the magic of their combination. There was commitment to their vocalizing. 

When the National Anthem is performed at a baseball game, it’s pretty pro forma. As the singer finally gets to the last lines – “O say, does that star-spangled banner yet wave…” – the crowd usually starts cheering, almost as if to rush things along and get the game started.

Not this time. The crowd didn’t want to miss the end. They didn’t start cheering until the chorus was finished. And it erupted. It was as if we heard this song that we’d heard more times than we can count for the first time ever.

I wasn’t expecting to be stirred by a song I don’t like. But I was – and I’ll tell you why.

Those kids aren’t what Trump and the livestock that support him have in mind about making America great again. And I’m sure the worst of them – Trump included – would never appreciate the care and devotion the Celia Cruz chorus put into the song. They would prefer you stand there listening to some band go through the motions. 

But the students are what truly makes America great. Their backgrounds are varied and fascinating. When they came together that chilly afternoon, they made a sound that haunted and inspired.

I will still bow my head for “The Star Spangled Banner” in sadness until this idiocy ends or it destroys me, whichever comes first. But as long as I can, I will fight for a country that includes and celebrates diversity, equity and inclusion – and understands that a mosaic is a far more interesting and wondrous work of art than a whitewash.

And, if Taylor Swift or Beyoncé can write a better anthem, please go at it.

Standard